GrillPartsReplacement Review: Aftermarket BBQ Grill Parts by Model Number, With a 45-Day Return Window
GrillPartsReplacement is an online store for BBQ grill repair parts, operated by Outdoor Trading LLC with an address in Arcadia, California. It sells grates, burners, heat plates, igniters and thermometers for gas, pellet and charcoal grills, listed by the grill brands and model numbers they are meant to fit — Weber, Char-Broil, Nexgrill, Traeger, Pit Boss, Napoleon and many more. Prices are in US dollars and the store ships from US warehouses.
This review covers what the store sells, how to match a part to your grill, what the "fits" wording means, and the shipping, return and warranty rules. One thing to know up front: the store states clearly that its parts are aftermarket, not original equipment.
At a glance Checked October 2026
GrillPartsReplacement suits grill owners who know their model number and want aftermarket repair parts, with free shipping over $19.99. The main catch is that the parts are not OEM, and a wrong guess can cost a 20% restocking fee plus return shipping.
- Best for: Owners repairing an older grill who know their model number and are comfortable with aftermarket parts backed by a one-year guarantee.
- Typical price: Most items cost about $30 to $190, with a typical listing around $70; the full range runs from about $5 to roughly $680.
- Shipping: Free standard shipping on qualifying orders over $19.99; most in-stock orders are processed within one business day, then approximately 3–7 business days.
- Returns: 45 calendar days for unused parts in original packaging; non-quality returns pay return shipping, and a 20% restocking fee may apply.
- Watch out for: Parts are aftermarket, not OEM; the FAQ allows a full-refund cancellation only within 12 hours of payment; almost every listing shows a compare-at price.
What GrillPartsReplacement sells
The catalogue is large — thousands of listings — and broader than the name suggests. The main groups are:
- Grates and grids. Cast iron cooking grates, porcelain-coated warming racks and stainless steel grids.
- Burners and heat plates. Burner tube kits, oval and U-shaped burners, heat plates and crossover tubes.
- Ignition and thermometers. Electronic igniter modules, push-button switches and replacement lid thermometers.
- Pellet grill parts. Hot rod igniters, auger motors, heat baffles and folding front shelves.
- Grill and griddle covers. Fitted covers listed with dimensions and grill models.
- Fire pits and fireplaces. Spark screens, tabletop propane fire pits and fireplace accessories.
- Non-grill parts. The store also lists dryer heating elements, car A/C condensers, generator parts, plumbing fittings and pet heating pads.
Finding the right part: model numbers, "fits" and aftermarket
Grill parts are not universal, so the key step happens before checkout. Each listing names the grill series it is designed for, then lists specific model numbers and, often, the original part numbers it replaces. The cast iron grates above, for example, say they replace Weber part numbers 7638 and 7639.
Practical points from the store's own pages:
- Use your model label, not just the series name. If unsure, the FAQ asks you to send photos of the grill and its model label before ordering; the team also emails a confirmation before shipping to check model and dimensions.
- Measure the old part. Several listings tell you to double-check the length of your existing burner tubes or grates, and one Char-Broil listing warns that Performance Series grills made in different years use 17-inch or 18-inch parts.
- Read the material line. Listings specify cast iron, porcelain-coated steel or stainless steel (sometimes stated as 304 stainless); covers are typically 420D oxford fabric.
On the "fits" wording: the store's About page says that, unless otherwise stated, its products "are aftermarket replacement parts and not OEM parts," and that "brand names, model numbers, and trademarks are used for compatibility and identification purposes only." Weber, Char-Broil, Traeger, Napoleon and the other grill names are trademarks of their owners, and the store does not claim to be affiliated with them. If you need a factory part, buy from the grill maker instead.
Prices
Prices are shown in US dollars. Most items cost between about $30 and $190, with a typical listing around $70; the full range runs from about $5 to roughly $680. Examples at the time of writing:
- Oval thermometer listed for Weber Q series grills: $29.99 (compare-at $39.99)
- Porcelain-coated steel warming rack for two Dyna-Glo 3-burner models: $49.99 (compare-at $99.99)
- Grill cover for Char-Broil Pro Series 4-burner grills: $55.99 (compare-at $99.99)
- 5-pack stainless steel heat plates for Char-Broil Performance Series 5-burner grills: $59.99 (compare-at $99.99)
- Electronic 4-outlet ignition module listed for Napoleon BIG32/BIG38/BIG44 and Pro 500 series: $71.99 (compare-at $99.99)
- Cast iron grates for Weber Spirit 300 series: $89.99 (compare-at $139.99)
Almost every listing shows a crossed-out compare-at price, so treat that figure as the store's reference price rather than proof of a deal.
Shipping
Per the shipping page, most in-stock orders are processed within one business day, and standard US delivery takes approximately 3–7 business days after shipment (not guaranteed). Standard shipping is free on qualifying orders over $19.99. Extra charges apply to Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Guam, the US Virgin Islands, APO/FPO addresses and other non-contiguous locations, and paid expedited options are offered.
The FAQ says the store ships to the United States and Canada, while the shipping page refers to international orders with costs calculated at checkout and duties paid by the buyer. Outside the US, check the checkout total. Multi-item orders may arrive separately.
Returns, cancellations and warranty
You can request a return within 45 calendar days of receiving your order, provided the part is unused, in its original packaging and in the condition it arrived. The fees depend on why you are returning it:
- Quality issues (damaged or defective): the store provides return instructions and charges no restocking fee.
- Non-quality returns (wrong part ordered, changed mind): you pay return shipping, "a 20% restocking fee may apply," and if the store provides a prepaid label its cost may be deducted from your refund.
- Original shipping charges are generally non-refundable unless the store made an error or the product has a quality issue.
Cancellations are where the pages differ. The return policy says the store will try to cancel any order that has not been processed or shipped. The FAQ is stricter: request cancellation within 12 hours of payment for a full refund; after that, it says the order is packed and you will be charged the 20% restocking fee plus return shipping.
For warranty, the FAQ states that "all parts are guaranteed for 1 year from the date of original receipt" against defects in materials and workmanship. It excludes improper installation, misuse, abuse and normal wear, and you will need your order number and email as proof of purchase.
Payment
The FAQ lists Visa, Mastercard, American Express and Discover credit cards, debit cards, PayPal, Shop Pay, Meta Pay, Google Pay, Apple Pay and Venmo. Support: support@grillpartsreplacement.com or 214-238-5374.
Who should buy from GrillPartsReplacement
- Owners repairing an older grill who know their model number and want burners, grates or heat plates without replacing the whole grill.
- Buyers comfortable with aftermarket parts backed by a one-year guarantee.
Think twice if you need genuine OEM parts, if you cannot confirm your model number or measurements, or if there is a real chance you will return the part — a 20% restocking fee plus return shipping makes a wrong guess expensive.
GrillPartsReplacement coupon codes
We did not find a verified public coupon code at the time of writing, and we do not publish codes we cannot confirm. The store has its own coupon page, but the codes shown there carried expiry dates that had already passed. The savings you can rely on are the listed sale prices and free standard shipping on orders over $19.99. Any working offers we find are listed on our GrillPartsReplacement coupons page.
Frequently asked questions
Is GrillPartsReplacement legit?
GrillPartsReplacement is operated by Outdoor Trading LLC, with an address in Arcadia, California, and ships from US warehouses. It publishes a 45-day return policy, and its FAQ guarantees parts for 1 year against defects. Payment options include PayPal, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and major cards, and support is listed at support@grillpartsreplacement.com and 214-238-5374. The main things to check are that parts are aftermarket, not OEM, and the 20% restocking fee on non-quality returns.
Are GrillPartsReplacement parts OEM?
Not unless a listing says otherwise. The store states that its products are aftermarket replacement parts and not OEM parts, and that brand names are used only to show compatibility.
How do I know a part fits my grill?
Match the model number on your grill's label to the product page and measure the old part. If in doubt, send photos to support first.
What is the return policy?
45 calendar days for unused parts in original packaging; non-quality returns may carry a 20% restocking fee plus return shipping.
Is there a warranty?
Yes — one year from receipt against defects, per the FAQ.
The bottom line
GrillPartsReplacement is a practical source for aftermarket grill repair parts: a deep catalogue organised by model number, free shipping over $19.99 and a one-year parts guarantee, with a clear statement that nothing is OEM. The catch is the cost of a wrong guess, so confirm your model number and measurements first, and ignore the crossed-out prices when judging value.
Disclosure: this article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Prices and policies were checked on the GrillPartsReplacement website at the time of writing and may change.